Connect with us

College Basketball

Rough Start to the Season? Christmas Coaching Wishlist for Every Budget

It’s that time of year again—when fanbases across the college basketball world begin dreaming of a fresh start on the sidelines after rough starts. Whether your team is struggling to meet expectations or you’re just ready for a change, there’s always room to ponder the possibilities. No matter your program’s level—be it a Power Five powerhouse, high-major contender, mid-major hopeful, or a low-major underdog—we’ve got you covered with a list of buy-low coaching options to add to your holiday wishlist.

Our list will focus on head coaches. While there are many talented assistants, we prefer to see proven resumes from those who have led programs successfully. Additionally, we favor coaches who have worked their way up the ladder, demonstrating their abilities at multiple levels along the way.

Contrast this with some blueblood assistants, who benefited from being part of prestigious coaching trees under legends like Roy Williams or Coach K. Too often, their main qualification for ascending from graduate assistant to a prime bench spot is having played for those Hall of Famers. Let’s be honest: it’s not difficult to look good recruiting or coaching when standing next to a legend at Kansas, UNC, or Duke.

Instead, give us the Nate Oats model—someone who started at the bottom and climbed the ranks on sheer coaching talent, not through the “good ol’ boy” silver-spoon network. With that in mind, let’s explore some realistic options for your team that fit this mold and coaches who may be looking or open for the call.

Top 50 Coaching Big Board

1Shaheen HollowaySeton HallHis alma mater, but it appears he needs more NIL support and might be poachable.
2Will WadeMcNeese StateHas paid his dues, and paying players is now in the open.
3Mike RhoadesPenn StatePenn State already lost one coach to a mid-level ACC school. Seems poachable.
4Bryce DrewGrand CanyonGC has more resources and upside than most realize. It will likely take a good P5 situation after a bad taste at Vandy.
5MWC ReturnersNev, BS, CS, NMI’d call Alford, Rice, Medved, and Pitino. They didn’t leave last year, less pressure, and a 6-bid league. Unlikely.
6Chris MackCharlestonSeems like he’s in no rush to get back to the P5, but I would still reach out.
7Josh SchertzSt. LouisOnly one year here, but worth a call. Unlikely to move this soon after.
8Ben McCollumDrakeD2 superstar already winning big. I think you make the call.
9David RileyWashington StIt’s only been a year, but does he really want to be in the new Pac-12 long term?
10Dave SmartPacificCanadian legend, has already improved Pacific by 100+ spots.
11Gregg MarshallIt’s been 5 years, if he has made the behavioral changes he should get another chance. At this point however you wonder as much as CBB has changed and the time off if he still is the same level of coach.
12Ryan OdomVCUSolid. P5 is the next step. Went to Utah State, so he seems to be ladder-climbing.
13Bob RicheyFurmanHas been at Furman for 8 years, so he must be selective. Doesn’t recruit transfers heavily, which is a red flag to me in this era.
14Ritchie McKayLibertyMakes the most sense to be Tony Bennett’s successor.
15Jerrod CalhounUtah StateFirst year at Utah State, but the last coach made the jump after one year.
16John BeckerVermontNot going so well this year, but the job he’s done in a state like Vermont with no NIL is amazing. How it translates is the question, but deserves a call.
17Russell TurnerUC IrvineHasn’t had a sub-150 KenPom rating in 13 years, at a school with a 155th budget. Very underrated coach with East Coast ties.
18Chris GerlufsenSan FranciscoVery solid. Top 85 team in three years.
19Brian WardleBradleyWinner at GB with two top-75 teams, now 4 straight top-100 teams at Bradley.
20Eric HendersonS. Dakota StWinning and producing quality transfers in a state like S. Dakota is impressive.
21Preston SpradlinJMUGood eye for talent, landing players like Broome and others to Morehead, results have followed.
22Ross HodgeNorth TexasGreat JUCO coach before a solid first year with a top-80 UNT team. People will start noticing soon.
23Mitch HendersonPrincetonPrinceton alum, would take the right job.
24Nevada SmithMarquetteCurrent Marquette assistant, Smith is a former D3 and GLeague head coach in Daryl Morey’s experimental lab, and worked under Nick Nurse prior.
25Joe PasternackUCSBHad a top-50 NET team in 2021 and has made two of the last four NCAA tournaments.
26Austin ClaunchUTSAFirst year at UTSA, but has 5 years of D1 coaching experience at only 35 years old. Was an assistant at Alabama last year as well.
27Bucky McMillanSamfordI like the results, but I don’t like his style of play. His leading scorer and rebounder averages 15 ppg in 19 minutes and plays 6th man minutes. Play him.
28Dustin KernsApp StateA top-85 team in Boone is no small feat.
29Scott CrossTroyRecovered nicely since his firing at UTA. Winning at Troy is very solid.
30Johnny TauerSt. ThomasD3 legend who took his D3 program to D1 and is already top-125 in year three. Does this translate everywhere? Coaching yes, recruiting not sure.
31Kevin OllieYes it flamed out at UConn and had some violations, but he did win a National Title and I don’t know of any coaches that pulled that off that couldn’t coach. People think he was handed a ready made champion but in reality he was handed a program on probation that was 20-14 the previous season and lost in the 1st round of the NCAA’s. He was most recently the interim coach for the Nets in 2024.
32Allan HussHigh PointHigh Point paid Tubby 1 million dollars and built a new facility. Would take the right job to jump, and he hasn’t really done much yet.
33Casey AlexanderBelmontHas gone a little sideways of late; would have been higher a few years ago.
34Takayo SiddleUNCWNot a fan of the 10-deep style, but he has won enough to get a job up the ladder.
35Bart LundyMilwaukeeGreat in D2, but Milwaukee is a tough place to win.
36Mike DeGeorgeCal PolyGreat in D2. Started off with a bang, with a projected 350th-ranked team, and has a top-150 NET.
37Steve DeMeoNWFSGreat in JUCO, 1 national title, assistant at Providence, St. John’s, UCF, Hofstra.
38Jim CrutchfieldNova Southeastern1 D2 national title. Probably too old at this point but deserving.
39Chris BridgesGeorgetown College2 NAIA titles, GA and student manager at Kentucky, currently 13-0.
40Jared GrassoHigh schoolA hit and run cost him the job at Bryant, but prior to that he had taken them to the NCAA and recruited one of the best low major transfer classes with the likes of Earl Timberlake and Doug Edert.
41Andy BrokemaFerris State1 D2 national title, and the highest-ranked Massey D2 ever. Elite 8 last year.
42Kris KorverNortheastern2 NAIA titles, 11-0 currently in NAIA.
43Tom BrownWest Texas A&M2 D2 Final 4s, 8-0 this year.
44Larry CordaroLSU AlexandriaTroy assistant, founded a NAIA program, and took them to 2 NAIA Final 4s.
45Matt LogiePoint Loma NazareneHighly successful in D2, took Montana State to the NCAA with a losing record last year in his first year.
46Hank PlonaWKUGreat JUCO, with solid results in his first 10 games at WKU.
47Stacy HollowellNew OrleansGreat NAIA with a national title. Coach just hired.
48Luke BarnwellTTU AssistantThe resume is very reminiscent of Kevin Keats when he got the UNCW job with incredible prep success. 224-39 at Sunrise Academy prior to Texas Tech.
49Shane HeirmanIncarnate Word82-7 with 2 HS basketball national championship games. The results aren’t there, but I like the makeup of his UIW team.
50Ben HowletteWest LibertyHas made the national finals in D2. 195–32.
51Craig DottyHouston Christian2 JUCO D3 National titles, 1 NAIA national title, 1st year in D1.
52Todd FranklinVincennes1 NJCAA title.
53Jay HerkelmanCoffeyville1 NJCAA title.
54Mark VandersliceUSC AikenSolid record in JUCO and D2, was at Toledo and Furman prior.
55Josh GamblinMidAmerica Christian1 NAIA national title.

More in College Basketball

Discover more from The Resource Nexus

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading